Hi all!
Thanks for the advice and great suggestions. Yalikavak was nice and quiet and the 4reasons was lovely. (The grounds, the pool and bistro were stunning, great views, but the suite itself, despite being named a "Passionate Suite", was very basic and overrated for the price per night (180 Euros). There wasn't even a bathtub, and there were these framed posters on the walls that looked like they were from the 80s)
Overall, we had a lovely weekend and enjoyed the boat trip so much that we did 2 of them 2 days in a row. Highly reccommend the Estini boat which departs just in front of Cumbali restaurant. The skipper is a jolly old guy and his wife makes lovely food!
Cumbali was also a very good restaurant and price of fish very reasonable. However, I would tell everyone to BEWARE of the TURTUGOIS restaurant just along the waterfront as U walk towards the new marina (It's the one with a nargile tea garden). They are one of those fish restaurants that try to rip U off blatantly!!
We saw this unusual dish, fish baked in salt which looked really interesting. They cover a whole fish in salt and set it on fire for about an hour to slow cook. So since we didn't want to wait, we pre-ordered it one day in advance. We booked a table and told the guy to have the fish ready for 8pm the next day. He asked for a deposit of 20 YTL to guarantee we would show up. When we asked him how much the fish would cost, he said about 45 YTL, or 50 max. depending on market price. So we agreed. When we arrived for dinner the next evening, not only did we have to WAIT 1 hr 30 minutes (!!!) in spite of pre-ordering the fish, he TRIED TO RIP US OFF! When the bill came, he claimed the fish cost 80 YTL!! Plus he added another 8 YTL for "service charge"
WHAT SERVICE?? We insisted we would only pay the agreed price MINUS our 20 YTL deposit. He said no and just walked away and started trying to "fish" potential customers walking by. So we got up and walked away as well, then he came after us and we again insisted we would only pay what we agreed on. Because we were in full view of other potential customers walking by and were quite agitated, he finally relented. So BEWARE of this place!